Asymmetric running is associated with pain during outdoor running
Our take
When I run outdoors with Achilles tendon pain, does shifting load onto my uninjured leg make the pain worse, and does running more often slow my recovery?
In runners returning to sport with Achilles tendinopathy, off-loading the injured leg (spending more ground contact time on the other leg) during outdoor running was linked to more pain in the injured tendon, and this link got stronger with more consecutive days of running without rest. The number of running sessions over two weeks did not worsen short-term symptom severity.
SupportsRead paper
Primary study17 ParticipantsLimited evidence
Key points
- Greater ground contact time on the contralateral (less symptomatic) leg corresponded to more pain in the injured tendon, and this relationship strengthened with each consecutive run day (b=-0.028, p<0.001).
- The total number of running bouts over two weeks was not associated with change in symptom severity (p=0.672), suggesting continued running was not detrimental in the short term.
- Ground contact time explained less than 5% of the variance in tendon pain, so other factors (running speed, ground incline, surface stiffness) likely matter too.
- Runners who off-load their injured leg may benefit from the clinically recommended 2 to 3 recovery days between runs.
- This was a small, two-week observational snapshot of a recovery process that can last 3 to 6 months or longer, so conclusions are preliminary.
How it was conducted
- Design
- Prospective observational study
- Setting
- Biomechanics laboratory and outdoor running
- Participants
- 17 recreational runners with Achilles tendinopathy in the return-to-sport phase
- Measures
- Symptom severity via VISA-A questionnaire; worst tendon pain via 0 to 10 numeric pain rating in daily logs; ground contact time via shoe-mounted wearable sensors (MilestonePod)
- Analysis
- Linear mixed model for pain vs ground contact time symmetry moderated by consecutive run days; multiple regression for number of runs vs VISA-A change, adjusted for run distance
What they found
- Greater ground contact time on the contralateral leg corresponded to increased ipsilateral tendon pain for each consecutive run day (b=-0.028, p<0.001).
- Number of running bouts was not associated with 2-week changes in VISA-A scores (p=0.672).
- Ground contact time accounted for less than 5% of the variance in tendon pain during outdoor running.
- Baseline symptom severity was low, with an average VISA-A score of 78 out of 100 in the most symptomatic leg.
- The wearable sensor detected gait parameters with comparable accuracy to lab-based motion capture (less than 12% percentage error).
Limitations
- Small sample size (17 runners) over a short 2-week window of a recovery process that can last 3 to 6 months or longer.
- Observational design cannot establish that off-loading causes pain; the relationship may run either direction.
- Low baseline symptom severity (average VISA-A 78/100) may create a floor effect, so a larger sample may be needed to detect meaningful change in symptoms.
- The heterogeneous sample and unknown duration in the return-to-sport phase, plus unmeasured factors like running speed, incline, and surface, limit how far results generalize.
Why it matters
- For patients
- If you are returning to running with Achilles pain, favoring your other leg may be tied to more pain, so building in 2 to 3 rest days between runs is reasonable, but continuing to run did not appear harmful over two weeks.
- For clinicians
- Monitoring loading symmetry (for example ground contact time) during real-world running may help identify return-to-sport patients who off-load the injured leg and could benefit from recovery days, though the metric alone explains little of the pain variance.
- For readers
- Wearable sensors can track running gait outdoors well enough to study tendon loading patterns, opening a path to monitor rehabilitation outside the clinic.
Source
doi:10.1016/j.ptsp.2024.02.006
Read the original paperMore Running studies
- The protective effect of preseason running workload against in-season hamstring strain injuries in elite soccer playersPrimary study
- How much running is too much? Identifying high-risk running sessions in a 5200-person cohort studyCohort study
- Effects of rocker-bottom shoes on the gait biomechanics of running and walking: a systematic reviewSystematic review
- Sprint running mechanics are associated with hamstring strain injury: a 6-month prospective studyCohort study
- Effects of artificially induced leg length discrepancy on treadmill-based walking and running symmetry in healthy college studentsPrimary study
- The dogma of running injuries: perceptions of adolescent and adult runnersPrimary study