Does adding exercise or physical activity to pharmacological osteoporosis therapy help
The verdict
If I'm already on osteoporosis medication, does adding exercise help my bones and lower my fracture risk?
Adding exercise or physical activity to osteoporosis medication may improve bone mineral density compared with medication alone, but the evidence on whether it actually reduces fractures is limited and inconsistent.
Mixed pictureRead paper
Primary studyLimited evidence
Key points
- This is a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized and controlled studies in people at high fracture risk who were taking anti-osteoporosis medication.
- Combining exercise with medication appeared to improve bone mineral density outcomes more than medication alone.
- The evidence on fracture reduction was limited and heterogeneous, so no firm conclusion could be drawn on fractures.
- Exercise is presented as a reasonable add-on to drug therapy for bone density, not as a replacement.
- More high-quality trials are needed before exercise can be said to lower fracture risk on top of medication.
How it was conducted
- Design
- Systematic review and meta-analysis
- Included studies
- Randomized controlled trials and controlled studies
- Participants
- People at increased fracture risk who were on pharmacological osteoporosis treatment
- Comparison
- Exercise or physical activity added to medication versus medication alone
- Outcomes
- Bone mineral density and fracture risk
What they found
- Combined exercise plus medication therapy may improve bone mineral density outcomes versus medication alone.
- Evidence for the fracture endpoint was limited and heterogeneous, so a reliable effect on fracture risk could not be established.
Limitations
- The evidence on fractures was limited and heterogeneous across studies.
- No fracture-specific effect size, confidence interval, or pooled estimate is reported in the available text.
- The number of included studies and total participants is not stated in the available text.
- Findings rest on a small and varied body of trials, so conclusions are tentative.
Why it matters
- For patients
- If you take osteoporosis medication, adding regular exercise may help your bone density, though it is not yet proven to further cut your fracture risk.
- For clinicians
- Exercise is a reasonable adjunct to pharmacotherapy for improving bone mineral density, but counsel patients that an added fracture-reduction benefit is not yet established.
- For readers
- This review signals a probable bone-density benefit from combining exercise with osteoporosis drugs, while flagging that the fracture evidence is too limited to be conclusive.
Source
doi:10.1007/s00198-023-06829-0
Read the original paperMore Exercise & Loading studies
- Competency and confidence in qualitative biomechanical assessment of exercise technique among exercise professionalsPrimary study
- Effect of adherence to exercise-based injury prevention programmes on the risk of sports injuries: a systematic review and meta-analysis of RCTsMeta-analysis
- Are maximal power and maximal aerobic capacity in older and very old adults dependent on their physical activityPrimary study
- Hamstring muscle architecture and microstructure changes following Nordic hamstring exercise trainingPrimary study
- Resistance training in pregnancy: systematic review and meta-analysis of pregnancy, delivery and fetal outcomesMeta-analysis
- Practical recommendations on stretching exercise: a Delphi consensus statement of international expertsConsensus